Femoral Neck Fractures
Elderly intracapsular fractures: Garden classification, nondisplaced vs displaced decision, fixation vs arthroplasty.
Sep 18, 2026 · 4 refs
Summary
Intracapsular fracture of the femoral neck in an older adult after a ground-level fall. The line may sit subcapital, transcervical, or basicervical.
Displacement can compromise retinacular supply to the head. Fixation then fails more often (nonunion, shortening, AVN) if reduction is poor or the patient is a poor fixation candidate.
TL;DR: Nondisplaced → usually fix when ready. Displaced → usually replace. Hemi vs THA follows pre-injury function and acetabular wear — not habit.
Not this topic: young high-energy femoral neck; intertrochanteric or subtrochanteric fractures.
Etiology
Most cases: fall from standing onto osteoporotic bone. Think fragility-fracture context (osteoporosis, falls, frailty). Add pathologic fracture to the differential when the story or films do not fit a simple fall.
Presentation
Clinical findings
- Hip or groin pain after a ground-level fall
- Often cannot bear weight
- Displaced limb: shortened and externally rotated
- Document pre-injury walking, cognition, and independence before arthroplasty counseling
- Red flags: open wound, neurovascular deficit, suspected pathologic lesion, delayed presentation, occult fracture with normal plain films
Labs
None diagnose the fracture. Preop labs (CBC, BMP, coagulation as indicated), type and screen, and geriatric co-management follow the local hip-fracture pathway.
Imaging
Painful hip after fall
│
▼
AP pelvis + dedicated hip AP/lateral
│
├─ Fracture visible ──► classify (Garden + location) ──► treat
│
└─ Films normal, still can't walk
│
▼
MRI (preferred)
CT if MRI unavailable
Report Garden displacement, neck location, and whether the pattern is basicervical.
Classification
Talk with Garden. Decide with nondisplaced vs displaced. Re-check location when metal choice might change (basicervical).
Garden
Garden 1961 — shared exam and board language.
| Garden | Film | Decision bundle |
|---|---|---|
| I | Incomplete or valgus-impacted | Nondisplaced / stable |
| II | Complete, not translated | Nondisplaced / stable |
| III | Complete, partially translated | Displaced / unstable |
| IV | Complete, fully translated | Displaced / unstable |
Pitfall: Garden I is still a fracture. Do not skip occult workup because the word "incomplete" sounds soft.
Practice collapse
┌──────────────────────┐
│ Elderly FN film │
└──────────┬───────────┘
│
┌───────────────┴───────────────┐
▼ ▼
┌─────────────────────┐ ┌─────────────────────┐
│ Nondisplaced / │ │ Displaced │
│ valgus-impacted │ │ (≈ Garden III–IV) │
│ (≈ Garden I–II) │ │ │
└──────────┬──────────┘ └──────────┬──────────┘
│ │
▼ ▼
Fixation if ready Arthroplasty
(selected nonop/hemi over fixation
per CPG options) (AAOS CPG)
Pre-injury function sits beside this split. It does not erase it.
Location
| Location | Meaning | Implant lean |
|---|---|---|
| Subcapital | Classic intracapsular | Nondisplaced / displaced algorithm |
| Transcervical | Mid-neck intracapsular | Same |
| Basicervical | Base of neck / capsule edge — often extracapsular behavior | May need SHS or nail, not automatic neck arthroplasty — pause and re-classify |
Basicervical: Wrong bucket → wrong implant.
Not covered here
Pauwels (line verticality / shear) → young high-energy Topics entry later. Do not force it onto low-energy elderly films.
Decision-making
Nondisplaced / valgus-impacted
Percutaneous fixation when medically ready is the usual path. AAOS older-adult guidance allows fixation, hemiarthroplasty, or nonoperative care to be considered for stable/impacted patterns.
Displaced
Arthroplasty over fixation for unstable/displaced elderly femoral necks.
Hemi vs THA
| Question | Practical answer | Key cite |
|---|---|---|
| Who gets which? | Match to pre-injury function and acetabular wear | OC teaching |
| Does THA clearly win on reoperation? | HEALTH: secondary procedures at 24 mo not significantly different | HEALTH |
| Function / harm tradeoff | Small function edge for THA; more serious adverse events with THA | HEALTH |
| Unipolar vs bipolar hemi | Can be similarly beneficial (CPG framing) | AAOS |
Timing and medical care
Optimize quickly. "Clearance" is not an open-ended delay. Missed anemia, hypotension, and second injuries still drive mortality harder than implant brand.
Treatment
Aftercare
VTE prophylaxis and early mobilization are part of the operation. Weight bearing to tolerance may be considered after surgery (CPG option language).
Operative choice summary
- Nondisplaced / valgus-impacted → Fixation if ready; selected nonop or hemi per AAOS CPG options
- Displaced → Arthroplasty over fixation (AAOS CPG strong recommendation)
- Hemi vs THA → Match to pre-injury function and acetabular wear; HEALTH shows similar reoperation rates with small function gain but more serious adverse events for THA
Watch for shortening / nonunion / AVN after fixation.
Techniques
Fixation (nondisplaced / selected)
Cannulated screws or sliding hip screw by pattern and bone quality.
FAITH trial (age ≥50, low-energy, treated with fixation): SHS vs multiple screws — reoperation at 24 mo similar; AVN more common with SHS.
Arthroplasty (most displaced)
Hemiarthroplasty or THA. Counsel dislocation and other complications if offering THA.
Basicervical
Confirm classification before a neck-arthroplasty default. May need SHS or nail, not automatic neck arthroplasty.
Practice variations
Cement vs cementless, approach, dual mobility: practice varies — see Controversies.
Controversies / Open Problems
- Automatic THA for every independent walker — HEALTH argues against a hard rule
- Acceptable delay to surgery in medically complex elders — need a timing/mortality primary cite before quoting hours
- Cemented vs cementless stems in fracture arthroplasty
- Occult fracture workup: MRI vs CT when MRI is scarce
- Basicervical classification: neck vs intertrochanteric-style fixation
- Screw configuration details beyond FAITH's overall result
High-yield / Exam
- Garden I–IV; action usually = nondisplaced vs displaced
- Displaced elderly → arthroplasty (AAOS CPG strong recommendation)
- Nondisplaced → fixation if ready
- HEALTH: similar reoperations; small THA function gain; more THA complications
- FAITH: similar reoperation; more AVN with SHS
- Know pre-injury function before counseling
Questions
Practice this Topic →- An independent 82-year-old with a displaced Garden IV femoral neck fracture is medically ready overnight. Whi…Ortho Skills (Real Life)
- A 27-year-old has a displaced femoral neck fracture after a high-energy crash. The next orthopedic priority i…Ortho Skills (Real Life)
- In the Garden classification still used on exams, a Garden IV femoral neck fracture is which pattern?Boards
References
- 01
Total hip arthroplasty or hemiarthroplasty for hip fracture (HEALTH)
HEALTH Investigators · 2019 · New England Journal of Medicine · rct
THA vs hemi for displaced elderly femoral neck: secondary procedures at 24 mo not significantly different; small THA function gain offset by more serious adverse events.
- 02
FAITH Investigators · 2017 · The Lancet · rct
SHS vs cancellous screws for low-energy femoral neck fixation (age ≥50): similar reoperation rates at 24 mo; AVN more common with SHS.
- 03
AAOS Clinical Practice Guideline: Management of Hip Fractures in Older Adults
2021 · American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (guidelines / AUC) · guideline
Strong recommendation: arthroplasty over fixation for displaced elderly femoral neck. Moderate options for stable/impacted patterns.
- 04
Low-angle fixation in fractures of the femoral neck
Garden RS · 1961 · The Bone & Joint Journal · other
Origin of the Garden classification still used for communication in exams and practice.
Related