Sign in

Menu

Femoral Neck Fractures

Garden, timing, fixation vs arthroplasty.

Aug 15, 2026 · 3 refs

At a glance

Femoral neck fractures in older adults are a race between physiology and the clock. Displaced fractures threaten the head’s blood supply; delay and poor reduction raise the cost of fixation failure.

Classify displacement, know the patient’s baseline mobility and cognition, and choose fixation vs arthroplasty as a judgment call — not a habit.

Classification

Garden (still the common language):

  • I — incomplete / valgus impacted
  • II — complete, nondisplaced
  • III — complete, partially displaced
  • IV — complete, fully displaced

In practice, many decisions collapse to nondisplaced vs displaced, plus patient physiology.

Decision-making

For the elderly patient:

  • Nondisplaced / valgus impacted → often percutaneous fixation if medically ready
  • Displaced → arthroplasty is frequently preferred (hemi vs total depends on activity, acetabulum, and surgeon/system factors)
  • Young patient with displaced fracture → urgent anatomic reduction and fixation; this is a different disease

Medical optimization should be rapid, not endless. Hypotension, anemia, and missed second injuries still kill more patients than imperfect implant choice.

Treatment

  • Fixation: cannulated screws or sliding hip constructs per pattern and bone quality
  • Arthroplasty: hemiarthroplasty vs THA — match to pre-injury function and acetabular wear
  • VTE prophylaxis and early mobilization are part of the operation
  • Watch for shortening / nonunion / AVN after fixation

High-yield / exam

  • Garden classification language
  • Displaced elderly → arthroplasty discussion
  • Young displaced → urgent reduction and fixation
  • Timing and medical co-management matter for mortality

Questions

On call and Boards items for this topic are coming.

Open the bank →

Your pearl

One line you’d tell a junior at 2am.

References

  1. 01

    Total hip arthroplasty or hemiarthroplasty for hip fracture (HEALTH)

    HEALTH Investigators · 2019 · New England Journal of Medicine · rct

    In older patients, THA vs hemiarthroplasty trade-offs depend on function and dislocation risk — not a one-size answer.

  2. 02

    AAOS clinical practice guideline on management of hip fractures in the elderly

    2014 · American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (guidelines / AUC) · guideline

    Supports timely surgery and structured decision-making for elderly hip fracture care.

  3. 03

    Low-angle fixation in fractures of the femoral neck

    Garden RS · 1961 · The Bone & Joint Journal · other

    Origin of the Garden classification still used for communication.

Related